Predator coexistence and herbivore suppression are shaped by predator functional types in intraguild predation modules

Abstract

Coexistence of multiple predators in ecological communities and their combined effects on the abundance and diversity of shared prey are often difficult to predict. In some theoretical models, predator coexistence is limited by antagonistic interactions, especially in the form of intraguild predation (IGP) that typically leads to out-competition between predators and high prey densities. However, empirical studies show that predator coexistence is common even in the presence of IGP. This discrepancy between theoretical expectations and empirical observations can be highly relevant for practical applications like using multiple natural enemies for pest suppression in agriculture. It is proposed that greater functional differences between natural enemies (i.e. predators) could reduce competition and overcome the negative effects of IGP, thereby promoting their coexistence and enhancing herbivore (i.e. prey) suppression. In this study, we theoretically explore this proposition. We develop a theoretical model based on the types of natural enemies of aphids to identify how functional differences between predators in IGP modules affect predator coexistence and herbivore suppression. We show that pairwise combinations of four functional predator types (ladybird, predatory bug, hoverfly, and parasitoid) can increase the coexistence range for different intraguild predation and competition strengths between predators (IGP symmetry), along a productivity gradient. This outcome depends on the external food input rate for the predatory bug and hoverfly types, and on their position as IG predator or IG prey. Herbivore suppression was primarily driven by IGP symmetry (i.e. the relative intraguild predation and exploitative competition strength between predators) and was especially pronounced in competitive-like modules where the IG predator was excluded for most scenarios. However, for some competitive-like IGP modules with predatory bug and hoverfly types, both predators can persist and provide a high herbivore suppression across increasing productivity. Our results can help explain experimental findings in conservation biocontrol, where coexistence between natural enemies is joined with effective herbivore suppression, and offer additional support for the role of functional diversity in reconciling theoretical predictions with experimental observations in multiple-predator communities.