A generalized adaptive harvesting model exhibits cusp bifurcation, noise, and rate-associated tipping pathways

Abstract

The sustainability of renewable resource harvesting may be threatened by environmental and socioeconomic changes that induce tipping points. Here, we propose a synthetic harvesting model with a comprehensive set of socioecological factors that have not been explored together, including market price and stock value, effort and processing costs, labour and natural capital elasticities, societal risk aversion, maximum sustainable yield (MSY), and population growth shape. We solve for harvest rate and stock biomass solutions by applying a timescale-separation between fast ecological dynamics and slow institutional adaptation that responds myopically to short-term net profit. The result is a cusp bifurcation with two composite bifurcation parameters: 1. consumptive scarcity{lambda} c or the ratio of market price-to-processing cost divided by MSY (leading to a pitchfork), and 2. non-consumptive scarcity{lambda} n or the stock value minus a scaled effort cost (leading to saddle-nodes or folds). Together, consumptive and non-consumptive scarcities create a cusp catastrophe. We further identify four tipping phenomena: 1. process (harvest rate) noise-induced tipping; 2. exogenous ({lambda}c) rate+process noise-induced tipping; 3. exogenous noise-induced reduction in tipping; and 4. exogenous cycle-induced reduction in tipping. Case 2 represents the first mechanistically motivated example of rate-associated tipping in socioecological systems, while cases 3 and 4 resemble noise-induced stability. We discuss the empirical relevance of catastrophe and tipping in natural resource management. Our work shows that human institutional behaviour coupled with changing socioecological conditions can cause counterintuitive sustainability and resilience outcomes.