Variation in white spruce needle respiration at the species range limits: a potential impediment to northern expansion

Abstract

White spruce (Picea glauca) spans a massive range from arctic treeline to temperate forests, yet the variability in respiratory physiology and related implications for tree carbon balance at the extremes of this distribution remain as enigmas. Working at both the most northern and southern extents of the white spruce distribution range more than 5000 km apart, we measured the short- term temperature response of dark respiration (R/T) at upper and lower canopy positions. R/T curves were fit to both polynomial and thermodynamic models so that model parameters could be compared among locations, canopy positions, and with previously published data. Respiration measured at 25{degrees}C (R25) was 68% lower at the southern location than at the northern location (0.73{+/-}0.15 vs. 2.27{+/-}0.02 mol m-2 s-1), resulting in a significantly lower (p< 0.01) intercept in R/T response in temperate trees. Only at the southern location did upper canopy leaves have a steeper temperature response than lower canopy leaves, likely reflecting steeper canopy gradients in light. No differences were observed in the maximum temperature of respiration. At the northern range limit respiration is nearly twice that of the average R25 reported in a global leaf respiration database. This large carbon cost likely challenges tree survival and contributes to restricting the location of the northern treeline. We predict that without significant thermal acclimation, foliage respiration will increase with projected end-of-the-century warming and will likely constrain the future range limits of this important boreal species. Summary StatementWhite spruce (Picea glauca) needle respiration at the northern limit of the species range is three times higher than at the southern range limit (when measured at 25 {degrees}C). This high carbon cost likely challenges tree survival and contributes to the location of the northern treeline.