Detecting tropical selective logging with SAR data requires a time series approach

Abstract

Selective logging is the primary driver of forest degradation in the tropics and reduces the capacity of forests to harbour biodiversity, maintain key ecosystem processes, sequester carbon, and support human livelihoods. While the preceding decade has seen a tremendous improvement in the ability to monitor forest disturbances from space, advances in forest monitoring have almost universally relied on optical satellite data from the Landsat program, whose effectiveness is limited in tropical regions with frequent cloud cover. Synthetic aperture radar (SAR) data can penetrate clouds and have been utilized in forest mapping applications since the early 1990s, but no study has exclusively used SAR data to map tropical selective logging. A detailed selective logging dataset from three lowland tropical forest regions in the Brazilian Amazon was used to assess the effectiveness of SAR data from Sentinel-1, RADARSAT-2 and PALSAR-2 for monitoring tropical selective logging. We built Random Forest models in an effort to classify pixel-based differences in logged and unlogged areas. In addition, we used the BFAST algorithm to assess if a dense time series of Sentinel-1 imagery displayed recognizable shifts in pixel values after selective logging. Random Forest classification with SAR data (Sentinel-1, RADARSAT-2, and ALOS-2 PALSAR-2) performed poorly, having high commission and omission errors for logged observations. This suggests little to no difference in pixel-based metrics between logged and unlogged areas for these sensors. In contrast, the Sentinel-1 time series analyses indicated that areas under higher intensity selective logging (> 20 m3 ha-1) show a distinct spike in the number of pixels that included a breakpoint during the logging season. BFAST detected breakpoints in 50% of logged pixels and exhibited a false alarm rate of approximately 10% in unlogged forest. Overall our results suggest that SAR data can be used in time series analyses to detect tropical selective logging at high intensity logging locations within the Amazon (> 20 m3 ha-1). These results have important implications for current and future abilities to detect selective logging with freely available SAR data from SAOCOM 1A, the planned continuation missions of Sentinel-1 (C and D), ALOS PALSAR-1 archives (expected to be opened for free access in 2020), and the upcoming launch of NISAR.