Thermal niche tracking in thirteen British temperate passerines

Abstract

Identifying how and why species vary in their ability to adjust to rapidly changing climates is a key challenge in ecology. While phenological shifts are well documented for birds and often studied in the context of tracking resource availability, less is known about the extent to which adjustments in phenology allow populations to track a consistent thermal niche. In particular, there has been little examination of how the extent of phenological thermal niche tracking compares over time versus space; a comparison that has the potential to inform on the underlying mechanisms. Here, we use data on breeding phenology derived from BTO Nest Record Scheme data, to examine the extent to which 13 passerine bird species track a consistent incubation thermal niche across years (both interannually and a year gradient) and along latitudinal and elevational gradients, and whether migrant and resident species differ in their tracking ability. Overall, we found support across species for partial tracking, with all species showing trends consistent with partial tracking across one or more axis, though for one species we could not reject the null hypothesis of no tracking. When we looked at average trends across species, we found significant tracking across interannual variation, latitude, and elevation, but not across a year trend. However, we found no evidence that tracking differs between residents and migrants, and for only a few species did we found evidence that species incubation thermal niche impacts on fitness. Taken together, our findings highlight the extent to which shifts in phenology can allow birds to track a thermal niche in a changing climate. The timing of a thermal niche provides a useful and widely-applicable yardstick to examine how changes in climate will impact on the abiotic conditions that populations experience.