Higher bat and bird γ-diversity in structurally complex forests is driven by distinct α- and β-diversity responses

Abstract

Effective conservation management and habitat restoration rely on understanding how biodiversity responds to environmental change. Centuries of silviculture have homogenized forests and their species communities globally, reducing biodiversity. To test whether restoring forest structural complexity can promote biodiversity, we conducted a large-scale, spatially explicit landscape experiment. At 11 sites across Germany, we compared bat and bird diversity in forests with experimentally enhanced heterogeneity by increasing deadwood and canopy complexity to homogeneous production forests. Both taxa were investigated by autonomous acoustic recorders and automatic species identification. We quantified within-patch (-), between-patch ({beta}-), and landscape-level ({gamma}-) diversity, emphasizing infrequent to highly frequent species for taxonomic, functional, and phylogenetic diversity. The pairwise comparisons of the sites were synthesized using a newly developed meta-analysis of rarefaction-extrapolation curves. {gamma}-diversity increased significantly in structurally heterogeneous forests for both taxa, albeit through distinct taxon-specific mechanisms. Bat {gamma}-diversity gains were primarily driven by higher {beta}-diversity, indicating greater dissimilarity in species assemblages among patches, while bird {gamma}-diversity increased via higher -diversity within patches. Bat diversity increases were mainly taxonomic, suggesting functional similarity in the communities, whereas birds showed the highest gains in functional diversity, indicating that experimental treatments resulted in greater trait dissimilarity. Our results provide experimental evidence under real-world conditions that {gamma}-diversity can be shaped by different diversity mechanisms. These patterns likely originate from differences in activity ranges, such as the large-scale movements of foraging bats in contrast to the more spatially restricted, territorial behavior of birds. This highlights the need for taxon-specific restoration strategies in homogenized landscapes.