Five Decades of Rariphotic Research: A Systematic Reviewof Trends, Biases, and Future Directions

Abstract

The rariphotic zone, typically spanning depths of approximately 130 to 300 meters, represents a key transition between light-dependent coral reef ecosystems and the aphotic deep sea. Despite its potential ecological importance, including its proposed role as a refuge for species exposed to climate-driven stress, rariphotic ecosystems remain poorly understood. In this study, we conducted a systematic review and synthesis of the scientific literature on these habitats from 1970 to 2025. Following the PRISMA 2020 protocol, we analyzed 185 studies to characterize the historical development of research, identify geographic and methodological biases, and assess shifts in research priorities over five decades. Our results show a marked increase in research effort over the last decade, driven in part by advances in underwater technologies such as Remotely Operated Vehicles (ROVs), Human Occupied Vehicles (HOVs), and Baited Remote Underwater Video Station (BRUVS). However, this growth remains uneven, with persistent biases toward benthic rather than pelagic studies and a strong concentration of research in geographically accessible regions. Multivariate analyses of research novelty indicate that technological innovation and the formal recognition of the rariphotic zone in 2018 corresponded with major structural shifts in literature. Although the rariphotic zone is now increasingly recognized as an ecologically distinct component of the reef continuum, it remains underrepresented in ecological theory and conservation frameworks. Future research should move beyond descriptive taxonomic mapping toward integrative, data-driven functional ecology, with particular emphasis on long-term monitoring and depth-stratified connectivity.