"Fuzzy specificity" shapes diazotroph diversity and composition in nodulating plants of the Southeastern USA

Abstract

Nitrogen-fixing symbioses, particularly those occurring in root nodules, are among the most consequential mutualisms in natural and agricultural systems and represent a globally important source of bioavailable nitrogen. Despite their importance, patterns of diversity and composition among diazotrophic symbionts--and the processes structuring those patterns in natural systems--remain poorly resolved, with competing hypotheses emphasizing ecological, or phylogenetic constraints on host-symbiont associations. Here, using a broad survey of nodulating plants from the southeastern United States, we examine how diazotrophic symbiont communities vary across host plant phylogeny, habitat context, and geographic origin. We find that host phylogeny is the primary determinant of symbiont composition, outweighing effects of fine-scale taxonomic identity. Symbiont associations are therefore structured mainly at deeper phylogenetic levels, consistent with phylogenetically constrained, or "fuzzy," host specificity. Likewise, nodule community diversity--potentially reflecting variation in host control over infection--differs primarily among higher-level clades rather than among closely related taxa. Habitat context also shapes nodule communities, but its influence is secondary and most evident in undisturbed environments. As well, nonnative legumes harbor distinct symbiont assemblages despite occupying similar habitats, whereas distantly related legume clades share symbionts across habitats, highlighting interactions among phylogeny, ecology, and geographic history. Overall, our results show that host phylogeny exerts the strongest influence on nodule microbial communities, likely reflecting evolutionary divergence in symbiotic function across major host lineages.