Age, Origin, and Biogeography: Unveiling the Factors Behind the Diversification of Dung Beetles

Abstract

The remarkable diversity and global distribution of dung beetles has long attracted the interest of researchers. However, there is still an ongoing debate on their origin, the reasons behind their diversity, and their path to global distribution. The two most prominent hypotheses regarding their origin and biogeographic history involve either vicariance events after the breakup of Gondwana, or an African origin and subsequent dispersal. One of the key reasons why the question is still disputed is a dependence on knowing the age of the dung beetles - a Mesozoic origin would favor the scenario of Gondwanan vicariance, a Cenozoic origin would suggest the out-of-Africa scenario. To help settle this longstanding question, we provide a taxonomically expanded phylogeny, with divergence times estimated under two calibration schemes suggesting an older or younger origin respectively. Using model-based inference, we estimate the ancestral area of the group and test for the influence of ranges on diversification rates. Our results support the hypothesis of an old age for Scarabaeinae and Gondwanan origin but remain ambiguous about the exact relation of range on lineage diversification.