Effects of alertness on perceptual detection and discrimination

Abstract

The level of alertness fluctuates throughout the day, exerting modulatory effects on human cognitive processes at any moment. However, our knowledge of how alertness level interacts with specific cognitive demands and perceptual rules of the task is still limited. Here we use perceptual decision-making paradigms to understand how alertness modulates the detection of a stimulus and the capacity to discriminate one stimulus from another. We analyzed data from four different experiments (113 participants in total): 1 - auditory masking detection; 2 - sensorimotor detection; 3 - auditory spatial discrimination; and 4 - auditory phoneme discrimination, and examined the performance of participants during the natural transition from awake (high alertness) to drowsy (low alertness). First, we fitted psychometric functions to the hit rates across different conditions of difficulty for EEG-defined high and low alertness metastable states, respectively. Second, we performed modelling of slope and threshold for the fitted curves as well as signal detection theory measures of perceptual sensitivity (d) and response bias (criterion). We found lower detection and discrimination sensitivity to stimuli as alertness level decreases, signalled by a shallower slope of the sigmoidal curve and a lower d, while the threshold increases slightly and equivalently across experiments during lower alertness. There was no change in the criterion to make the decision during the transition. These results suggest that reduced alertness generally decreases the quality of perceptual decision-making. Zooming in, we observed that the decrease in sensitivity measured by slope was stronger for discrimination than for detection decisions, indicating that lower alertness impairs the precision of decisions in discriminating alternatives more than identifying the presence of a stimulus around the threshold. Taken together, these results suggest that alertness has a common effect on perceptual decision-making and differentially modulates detection and discrimination decisions.