Data requirements for accurate extinction-risk prediction in bistable populations

Abstract

Understanding and predicting extinction risk is a central challenge in population biology. Mathematical models incorporating Allee thresholds are commonly used to understand population dynamics and to assess extinction risks. Inaccurate predictions can have serious consequences for conservation management. In this simulation study, we develop a likelihood-based inference and prediction workflow to estimate parameters, including the Allee threshold and population diffusivity parameters, using noisy count data generated using a well-defined discrete model. Although parameters are identifiable according to commonly used criteria, the accuracy of resulting predictions depends strongly on the quantity, quality, collection time and spatial resolution of the data. Our workflow demonstrates that seemingly reliable parameter estimates can lead to inaccurate predictions, highlighting the need for careful consideration of data quality and quantity to guide extinction-risk modelling and prediction. Open source software is provided on GitHub to replicate and extend all results considered.