Unveiling the intertwined roles of the spatial-temporal environment and behavioural modes in animal movement

Abstract

O_LIAnimal movement arises from complex interactions between animals and their heterogeneous environment, making it challenging to capture the movement process in a single analysis. This has lead to a bias towards lower-dimensional representations of the process in such analyses. In order to better understand animal movement, its multiple components should be included and addressed simultaneously. C_LIO_LIWe present an analytic framework that integrates the behavioural, spatial, and temporal components of the movement process and their interactions, and allows for assessing the relative importance of these components. We propose a daily cyclic covariate to represent temporally cyclic movement patterns, for example diel variation in activity, and combine the three components in multi-modal Hidden Markov Models. We compare the statistical fits of models that include or exclude any of the behavioural, spatial and temporal components, and perform variance partitioning on the model that included all components to assess their relative importance to the movement process, both in isolation and in interaction. C_LIO_LIWe apply our framework to a case study on the movements of zebra, wildebeest and eland antelope in a South African reserve. Behavioural modes impacted movement the most, followed by diel rhythms and then the spatial environment (i.e. tree cover and terrain slope). Interactions between the components often explained more of the movement variation than the marginal effect of the spatial environment did on its own. Omitting components from the analysis led either to failure to detect relationships between input and response variables, resulting in overgeneralisations when drawing conclusions about the movement process, or to erroneously detecting spurious relationships, resulting in factually incorrect conclusions. C_LIO_LIOur analytic framework can be used to study animal movement by integrating the different components of the movement process, thereby preventing incomplete or overly generic ecological interpretations. We demonstrate that understanding the drivers of animal movement, and ultimately the ecological phenomena that emerge from it, critically depends on considering the various components of the movement process, and especially the interactions between them. C_LI Data/code for peer review statement: the data and code needed to reproduce the study and results are uploaded as a file with the initial submission.