A Statistical Review of Virus Reduction in Coagulation, Flocculation, and Sedimentation Treatment Processes

Abstract

Coagulation, flocculation, and sedimentation (CFS) is widely applied as a combined unit process in the treatment of drinking water, wastewater, and recycled water; however, virus reduction through CFS has not been sufficiently characterized to assign pathogen log reduction value (LRV) credits. This study collected data through a systematic review that yielded over 1000 LRVs from 43 manuscripts covering 46 viruses to characterize virus reduction through CFS. The results demonstrate that CFS is effective at reducing viruses, with 68% of virus LRVs greater than 1. A mixed-effects model was used to identify potential mechanisms of virus reduction with ferric and aluminum coagulants, as well as factors associated with variability in performance. Key insights from the model show that virus reduction is: (1) improved at lower pH, similar to natural organic matter (NOM) reduction, (2) lower in secondary effluent than surface water for drinking water treatment, (3) virus-dependent, and (4) dependent on virus enumeration methods, with lower LRVs observed for molecular techniques. These findings demonstrate the potential for CFS to provide consistent and explainable virus reduction, potentially establishing a foundation for regulatory crediting in potable reuse applications. Future crediting frameworks will need to account for the factors impacting performance to accurately quantify and assign credit for virus reduction.