Evolutionary history mediates population response to rapid environmental change through within-generational and transgenerational plasticity

Abstract

Rapid environmental change is affecting many organisms; some are coping well but many species are in decline. A key mechanism for facilitating success following environmental change is phenotypic plasticity. Organisms use cues to respond phenotypically to environmental conditions; many incorporate recent information (within-generation plasticity) and information from previous generations (transgenerational plasticity). We extend an existing evolutionary model where organisms utilize within-generational plasticity, transgenerational plasticity, rapid evolution, and bet-hedging. We show how, when rapid evolution of plasticity is not possible, the effect of environmental change (altering the environment mean, variance, or autocorrelation, or cue reliability) on population growth rate depends on selection for within-generation plasticity and transgenerational plasticity under historical environmental conditions. We then evaluate the predictions that populations adapted to highly variable environments, or with greater within-generational plasticity, are more likely to successfully respond to environmental change. We identify when these predictions fail, and show environmental change is most detrimental when previously reliable cues become unreliable. When multiple cues become unreliable, environmental change can cause deleterious effects regardless of the populations evolutionary history. Overall, this work provides a general framework for understanding the role of plasticity in population responses to rapid environmental change.