Recovery mode: Marine protected areas enhance the resilience of kelp species from marine heatwaves

Abstract

Marine protected areas (MPAs) can promote population recovery from climate change impacts by reducing local stressors, such as fishing. However, with extreme climatic events such as marine heatwaves (MHWs) increasing in frequency and duration, it remains unclear whether MPAs enhance recovery following these acute perturbations, and how recovery varies across species and ecological traits (e.g., sedentary vs mobile species). We used 16 years (2007-2022) of kelp forest monitoring data in Isla Natividad, Baja California Sur, Mexico, to assess the impact of the 2014-2016 MHWs on fish and invertebrate communities. Then we evaluated the impact and recovery from the MHWs of economically and ecologically important invertebrate species inside and outside two fully protected marine reserves. We found that the 2014-2016 MHWs, which were the most intense and persistent ever observed in Isla Natividad, impacted invertebrates but not fish biomass. Marine reserves did not confer resistance to the MHWs, however, reserves did enhance the recovery of some species after the MHWs. Inside marine reserves, abalone (Haliotis spp.) and wavy turban snail (Megastraea spp.) (benthic sedentary invertebrates) recovered to pre-heatwave biomass after two years and spiny lobster (Panulirus interruptus) (benthic mobile invertebrate) after four years. Outside the reserves, abalone recovered after three years, while the other two species never recovered. The warty sea cucumber (Apostichopus parvimensis) population collapsed after the MHWs and never recovered inside nor outside the reserve. Remarkably, abalone biomass had an outstanding and sustained recovery inside reserves, with a 5.6-fold increase in biomass after the MHWs, which was over three times higher than the recovery reported outside the reserve. Our analysis of long-term monitoring data shows that marine reserves cannot prevent adverse impacts from extreme climatic events but can enhance species recovery following these events. Benefits conferred by marine reserves, however, are species-specific and may be limited to species with limited dispersal and localized population dynamics.