Multispecies relations shape bird-feeding practices

Abstract

While humans often feed birds in their backyards, there is growing awareness that this has positive and negative effects on local biodiversity. Whether the observed species assemblage shapes human activities has, however, rarely been investigated. We analyzed 15,088 open-ended answers from 9,473 Finnish respondents about why they have increased or reduced feeding birds. They mentioned 58 avian and non-avian species linked to changed practices. The main reasons for change were 1) respondents relation to non-human species, 2) respondents relation to other humans and 3) relations between non-human species. Most taxa and reasons could lead to both increase or decrease in feeding, although the direction was context-dependent. We suggest that bird-feeding is an interactive process where the species community strongly affects feeding practices, which in turn can affect community composition. Recognising this process is crucial for understanding the effects of bird-feeding on both humans and nature and providing more nuanced guidance.