Inverted trophic pyramids and transient fish community reorganization in large reservoirs

Abstract

The rapid global expansion of dams has significantly reshaped freshwater ecosystems, yet long-term trophic dynamics and food-web stability within reservoirs remain underexplored. This study examines the reorganization of fish communities induced by the trophic surge following dam construction and river impoundment. We used the predator-to-consumer mass ratio (PCMR) as a proxy for trophic pyramid structure to track changes in fish biomass distribution across three large boreal reservoirs in Quebec, Canada, over 20 years, using data from before and after impoundment. We found transient top-heaviness events (i.e., PCMR values > 1; predator accumulation), characterized by a hump-shaped trajectory of the PCMR values in two reservoirs (Opinaca and Robert Bourassa). The third reservoir (Caniapiscau) showed a gradual increase in top-heaviness but did not exhibit a clear transient pattern. The magnitude and duration of top-heaviness varied across reservoirs, potentially due to differences in the system's capacity to receive and accumulate nutrients, which are driven by water residence time and reservoir size. This research provides a conceptual framework for understanding the long-term trophic dynamics of reservoirs, which can help inform the development of more effective management strategies to preserve ecological health in these ecosystems.