The influence of liver fluke infection on production in sheep and cattle: a meta-analysis

Abstract

Liver flukes (Fasciola spp) are important parasites of sheep and cattle across the world, causing significant damage to animal health and productivity due to both acute and chronic infection. Many comprehensive reviews have discussed the results of decades of research into the impact of fluke infection on livestock performance traits such as weight gain and milk production. While fluke are considered to be important, there have been no attempts to collate previous research in a quantitative manner, and nor has there been an attempt to determine why some studies find substantial effects of fluke while others conclude that effects of fluke on animal performance are negligible. In this study, we used meta-analysis to provide quantitative estimates of the impact of liver fluke on animal performance, and to identify elements of study design that influence the conclusions of such studies. A literature search provided 233 comparisons of performance in "fluke-infected" and "uninfected" animals. We standardized these data as log response ratios and calculated effect size variances in order to weight studies by their sample size and accuracy of their estimates. We performed multi-level meta-analysis to estimate effects of fluke infection in five traits: daily weight gain (N = 77); live weight (N = 47); carcass weight (N = 84); total weight gain (N = 18) and milk production (N = 6). There were significant negative effects of fluke infection on daily weight gain, live weight and carcass weight (9%, 6% and 0.6% reductions in performance, respectively), but not total weight gain or milk production. We then used mixed-effects meta-analysis to estimate the impact of moderator variables, including host, fluke, and study design factors, on study outcomes. We found that, in general, studies that gave experimental infections found generally larger effects of fluke than observational or drug studies; younger animals were more likely to suffer the effects of fluke infection on daily weight gain; and that effects on live weight increased across the course of an experiment. Our results provide the first quantitative estimate of the importance of liver fluke on performance across studies and highlight the elements of study design that can influence conclusions. Furthermore, our literature search revealed areas of research into liver fluke that could be the subject of greater effort, and types of study that could form the basis of future meta-analyses.