Phylogenetic signal is associated with the degree of variation in root-to-tip distances

The phylogenetic information contained in sequence data is partly determined by the overall rate of nucleotide substitution in the genomic region in question. However, phylogenetic signal is affected by various other factors, such as heterogeneity in substitution rates across lineages. These factors might be able to predict the phylogenetic accuracy of any given gene in a data set. We examined the association between the accuracy of phylogenetic inference across genes and several characteristics of branch lengths in phylogenomic data. In a large number of published data sets, we found that the accuracy of phylogenetic inference from genes was consistently associated with their mean statistical branch support and variation in their gene tree root-to-tip distances, but not with tree length and stemminess. Therefore, a signal of constant evolutionary rates across lineages appears to be beneficial for phylogenetic inference. Identifying the causes of variation in root-to-tip lengths in gene trees also offers a potential way forward to increase congruence in the signal across genes and improve estimates of species trees from phylogenomic data sets.