Plastic germination, temporal niche partitioning, and emergent assortative mating in annual plants

Temporal fluctuations in environmental conditions can promote coexistence via the storage effect, which requires a mechanism buffering different variants during adverse periods. This mechanism readily occurs in annual plants whose seeds do not necessarily germinate each year but instead remain dormant in a seed bank. Yet, how plasticity in germination timing affects genetic diversification and ecological speciation under temporally varying conditions remains poorly understood. Here, we use mathematical modeling and individual-based simulations to investigate the joint evolution of a combination of traits controlling plastic seed germination and plant fecundity under interannual environmental fluctuations. We show that adaptive plasticity in germination readily evolves via a genetic association between seed and plant traits, allowing seeds to germinate preferentially in years favorable for their subsequent growth and reproduction. Such adaptive plasticity enhances the storage effect and promotes genetic divergence among different morphs specialized to distinct yearly conditions. Because these morphs germinate preferentially in different years, plastic germination indirectly generates temporal assortative mating, thereby maintaining genetic associations among seed and plant traits despite the absence of physical linkage between loci controlling these traits. This temporal assortative mating ultimately leads to reproductive isolation between morphs, thus laying the foundation for ecological speciation. Our findings show that adaptive plasticity and genetic diversification are not mutually exclusive but can interact synergistically to enhance biodiversity.