bioRxivBioengineering
Synergies analysis produces consistent results between motion analysis laboratories
B. A. MacWilliams, M. L. McMulkin, A. Rozulmalski, M. H. Schwartz
Abstract
AimThe dynamic motor control index during walking (walk-DMC) has been shown to be related to patient outcomes and there has been an increasing interest from motion analysis centers regarding using this metric in their own practice. However, the methods for computing the index reported in the literature are not consistent. Here we propose a standardized method and investigate if this leads to results that are consistent between laboratories. MethodComparisons of typically developing controls are made between three independent motion analysis centers. Comparisons are also made between the proposed and previously published methods. A program script to compute the walk-DMC was used for this study and is made freely available with this manuscript. ResultsUsing this script, results are highly consistent between three participating centers. The currently proposed method results in a wider distribution of walk-DMC values than those previously reported. InterpretationUsing consistent processing methods, synergy measures are equivalent between centers. The major differences between current and published data are attributed to the use of concatenation of several walking trials.
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Identifying differences in gait adaptability across various speeds using movement synergy analysis
David Ó’Reilly, Peter Federolf·PLoS ONEPeer-reviewed·Jan 7, 2021
- MOTOR MODULES ARE LARGELY UNAFFECTED BY PATHOLOGICAL WALKING BIOMECHANICS: A SIMULATION STUDY
Mohammad Rahimi Goloujeh, Jessica L. Allen·Journal of NeuroEngineering and RehabilitationPeer-reviewed·Jan 30, 2025
- Speed-driven transitions between discrete and rhythmic dynamics in walking revealed by kinematic smoothness and muscle synergies
Giulia Panconi, Diego Minciacchi, … Nadia Dominici·bioRxiv·Apr 13, 2026
- Slow walking synergies reveal a functional role for arm swing asymmetry in healthy adults: a principal component analysis with relation to mechanical work.
David Ó’ Reilly·Gait & PosturePeer-reviewed·Jan 27, 2021
- Milliseconds matter: Biomechanical inverse dynamics analysis is highly sensitive to imperfect data synchronization
Koen K. Lemaire, Arthur D. Kuo·bioRxiv·Jun 24, 2024
- Spatial and temporal muscle synergies provide a dual characterization of low-dimensional and intermittent control of upper-limb movements
Cristina Brambilla, Manfredo Atzori, … Alessandro Scano·NeurosciencePeer-reviewed·Jan 26, 2023