Intraspecific genetic and phenotypic diversity: parallel processes and correlated patterns?

Intraspecific diversity plays a key role for evolutionary and ecological dynamics. It is the raw material on which acts selection, it improves species and communities resilience to disturbance and it affects the way species modulate their biotic and abiotic environment. Understanding patterns and underlying determinants of genetic and phenotypic intraspecific diversity is therefore of critical importance for ecological, evolutionary and conservation sciences. Here, focusing on two freshwater fish species (Gobio occitaniae and Phoxinus phoxinus) sampled across a large river basin (the Garonne-Dordogne river basin, France), we used causal analyses to test for genetic-phenotypic intraspecific diversity correlations (GPIDCs) and unravel the processes underlying intraspecific diversity patterns. Genetic diversity was assessed using microsatellite markers and phenotypic diversity was assessed through geometric morphometrics. We found disparities in the distribution of genetic and phenotypic diversity in the two species, suggesting higher level of local adaptation in G. occitaniae, and our results revealed common and contrasted processes shaping diversity at the - and {beta}-level. At the -level, we found no GPIDC in both species despite common relations between isolation and genetic and phenotypic -diversity in G. occitaniae. At the {beta}-level, we found no GPIDC in P. phoxinus but we found a positive GPIDC in G. occitaniae. This correlation appeared to be caused by a direct impact of one facet of intraspecific diversity on the other, and we speculated that it could originate from positive assortative mating. Studying neutral genetic diversity and phenotypic diversity within an integrative framework appears as a valuable way of deciphering the complex and diverse impacts of neutral and adaptive processes on intraspecific diversity patterns.