bioRxivNeurosciencePreprint
Stimulus domain transfer in recurrent models for large scale cortical population prediction on video
Fabian H. SinziD, Alexander S. EckeriD, Paul G. FaheyiD, Edgar Y. WalkeriD, Erick Cobos, Emmanouil FroudarakisiD, Dimitri YatsenkoiD, Zachary PitkowiD, Jacob ReimeriD, Andreas Savas ToliasiD
Abstract
To better understand the representations in visual cortex, we need to generate better predictions of neural activity in awake animals presented with their ecological input: natural video. Despite recent advances in models for static images, models for predicting responses to natural video are scarce and standard linear-nonlinear models perform poorly. We developed a new deep recurrent network architecture that predicts inferred spiking activity of thousands of mouse V1 neurons simulta-neously recorded with two-photon microscopy, while accounting for confounding factors such as the animals gaze position and brain state changes related to running state and pupil dilation. Powerful system identification models provide an opportunity to gain insight into cortical functions through in silico experiments that can subsequently be tested in the brain. However, in many cases this approach requires that the model is able to generalize to stimulus statistics that it was not trained on, such as band-limited noise and other parameterized stimuli. We investigated these domain transfer properties in our model and find that our model trained on natural images is able to correctly predict the orientation tuning of neurons in responses to artificial noise stimuli. Finally, we show that we can fully generalize from movies to noise and maintain high predictive performance on both stimulus domains by fine-tuning only the final layers weights on a network otherwise trained on natural movies. The converse, however, is not true.
- organism: mouse
- assay: electronic health records
- research focus: trajectory inference
- approach: deep learning
Abstract summary
Claude Opus 5.5 · xhigh effort · 18 Oct 2026 · from the abstract · CC BY-ND 4.0
A deep recurrent encoding model predicts spiking of thousands of mouse V1 neurons during natural video and carries over to noise stimuli when only its last layer is retrained.
Response models for visual cortex are mostly built for static images, and standard linear-nonlinear models handle natural video poorly, even though video is the input awake animals actually receive. For in silico experiments to be worth testing in the brain, a video-trained model also has to generalise to parameterized stimuli such as band-limited noise.
Key results
ClaimedA deep recurrent architecture predicts inferred spiking of thousands of simultaneously recorded mouse V1 neurons from natural video while absorbing gaze position, running state and pupil dilation as confounds.
Stated as the model's capability; the abstract reports no predictive-performance metric, no held-out correlation and no comparison against the linear-nonlinear baselines it criticises. · Abstract
SuggestedTraining on natural images transfers to artificial stimuli: the model recovers neurons' orientation tuning measured with noise.
Reported as correct prediction of orientation tuning under artificial noise stimuli; no tuning-curve error, preferred-orientation accuracy or neuron counts are given. · Abstract
SuggestedFine-tuning only the final layer weights of a movie-trained network gives good prediction on both movies and noise, but the reverse direction fails.
Described as full generalisation from movies to noise with performance kept on both domains, with the converse explicitly not holding; no numbers accompany either direction. · Abstract
Methods, data and reproducibility
A deep recurrent network trained as a system identification model: it maps natural video to the inferred spiking of many simultaneously recorded mouse V1 neurons, with gaze position, running and pupil dilation modelled as confounding factors. Stimulus domain transfer was probed by testing on noise stimuli and by retraining only the final layer weights.
- two-photon microscopy recordings of mouse primary visual cortex (V1) neurons during natural video presentation · mouse · n = thousands of neurons recorded simultaneously
- responses to band-limited noise and other parameterized artificial stimuli, used to test domain transfer · mouse
- Methods & tools
- two-photon microscopy, deep recurrent neural network
- Reproducibility gaps
- No repository, dataset identifier or software release is named in the abstract.
Limitations (3)
- Transfer is one-directional: the authors state that generalising the other way, from noise to movies, does not work. · stated by the authors
- No predictive-performance numbers, baselines or ablations appear in the abstract, so the gain over linear-nonlinear models cannot be judged from the text. · noted in this summary
- Evidence comes from mouse V1 recordings only, with no indication of how many animals or sessions contributed. · noted in this summary
Read this if you fit encoding models to large population recordings and need one that handles natural video yet still transfers to parameterized stimuli for in silico experiments.
- Citations
- 42
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Deep convolutional models improve predictions of macaque V1 responses to natural images
Santiago A. Cadena, George H. Denfield, … Alexander S. Ecker·PLoS Computational BiologyPeer-reviewed·Apr 23, 2019
- How well do models of visual cortex generalize to out of distribution samples?
Yifei Ren, Pouya Bashivan·PLoS Computational BiologyPeer-reviewed·May 31, 2024
- Temporal prediction captures key differences between spiking excitatory and inhibitory V1 neurons
Luke Taylor, Friedemann Zenke, … Nicol Spencer Harper·bioRxiv·May 12, 2024
- Generalization in data-driven models of primary visual cortex
Konstantin-Klemens Lurz, Mohammad Bashiri, … Fabian H. Sinz·bioRxiv·Oct 5, 2020
- Multimodal Deep Learning Model Unveils Behavioral Dynamics of V1 Activity in Freely Moving Mice
Aiwen Xu, Yuchen Hou, … Michael Beyeler·bioRxiv·May 30, 2023
- Cortical response to naturalistic stimuli is largely predictable with deep neural networks
Meenakshi Khosla, Gia H. Ngo, … Mert Rory Sabuncu·Science AdvancesPeer-reviewed·May 28, 2021