NeuroImageNeurosciencePeer-reviewed journal article
Neural entrainment to pitch changes of auditory targets in noise
Xiaoxuan GuoiD, Guangting MaiiD, Yousef MohammadiiD, Ester BenzaquéniD, Ekaterina A YukhnovichiD, William SedleyiD, Timothy David GriffithsiD
Abstract
Neural entrainment to certain acoustic features can predict speech-in-noise perception, but these features are difficult to separate. We measured neural responses to both natural speech-in-noise and stimuli (auditory figure-ground) that simulate speech-in-noise without any acoustic or linguistic confound such as stress contour and semantics. The figure-ground stimulus is formed by multiple temporally coherent pure-tone components embedded in a random tone cloud. Previous work has shown that discrimination of dynamic figure-ground based on the fundamental frequency (F0) of natural speech predicts speech-in-noise recognition independent of hearing and age. In this study, we compared the brain substrate for the figure-ground analysis based on the F0 contour and a statistically similar 1/f contour with speech-in-noise. We used the temporal response function to predict the electroencephalography responses to the frequency trajectories of the auditory targets. We demonstrate that the brain significantly tracked the pitch changes in both AFG conditions (F0 and 1/F tracking) and a sentence-in-noise condition (F0 tracking) at similar latencies, but at similar magnitudes only when tracking the F0 contour. The pitch-tracking accuracy was consistently high across the delta and theta bands for the AFG condition but not for speech. Sensor-space analysis revealed that speech-in-noise performance correlated with the positive peak amplitude of the F0 figure-ground at 100 ms. Source-space analysis revealed bilateral temporal lobe and hippocampal generators, and strong tracking in the superior parietal lobe for auditory figures and natural speech. In conclusion, our findings demonstrate that the human brain reliably tracks the F0 trajectory of both speech and a non-linguistic figure in noise, with speech tracking showing reduced accuracy in the theta band compared to figure-ground tracking. Despite the difference in prediction accuracy, we reveal striking similarities in neural entrainment patterns and source locations between the two paradigms. These results suggest that neural entrainment engages high-level cortical mechanisms independent of linguistic content. Furthermore, we show that TRF peak amplitude serves as a potential biomarker for speech-in-noise ability, highlighting possible clinical applications.
- organism: human
- assay: electronic health records
- research focus: differential expression
- approach: statistical model
- Citations
- 6
- FWCI
- 3.40
- Field percentile
- top 7%
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Predicting Speech in Noise Perception using Measures of Neural Entrainment
Brett M. Bormann, Zacaria Balky, … Lee M. Miller·bioRxiv·Sep 11, 2026
- Auditory and Language Contributions to Neural Encoding of Speech Features in Noisy Environments
Jiajie Zou, Jun Feng, … Nai Ding·NeuroImagePeer-reviewed·Feb 26, 2019
- Effect of task and attention on neural tracking of speech
Jonas Vanthornhout, Lien P. Decruy, Tom Francart·Frontiers in NeurosciencePeer-reviewed·Sep 16, 2019
- The frequency dependence of EEG-speech envelope tracking does not reflect the rates of speech units or pitch
Michael P. Thornton, Tobias Reichenbach·bioRxiv·Jun 16, 2026
- Neural tracking as a diagnostic tool to assess the auditory pathway
Marlies Gillis, Jana Van Canneyt, … Jonas Vanthornhout·Hearing ResearchPeer-reviewed·Sep 14, 2022
- Envelope reconstruction of speech and music highlights unique tracking of speech at low frequencies
Nathaniel J. Zuk, Jeremy W. Murphy, … Edmund C. Lalor·PLoS Computational BiologyPeer-reviewed·Sep 17, 2021