Theoretical physical color gamuts define luminosity and naturalness perceptual limits in natural scenes

Realism in augmented reality (AR) hinges on the seamless blending of virtual elements into real-world environments. One possible factor influencing this realism may be the physical gamut: an internal representation of all perceivable colors within a natural scene. Previous studies on luminosity thresholds suggest that this gamut, rooted in optimal colors theory, constrains perceptual judgments. While promising, such findings were based on abstract and two-dimensional stimuli only. Before extending this framework to more realistic AR scenarios, an essential next step is to assess whether the physical gamut theory also applies to naturalistic stimuli. This study addresses that gap. Our results reveal that the physical gamut remains a valid construct for natural objects viewed in realistic scenes. Moreover, observers judgments of luminosity thresholds appear guided not only by a criterion of self-luminosity, but also by an implicit sense of naturalness. These insights pave the way for exploring AR realism through the lens of physical gamut theory.