Contingency Inverts Mammalian Herbivore Evolution in Australia

Abstract

The rise of Neogene herbivores with high-crowned (hypsodont) molar teeth has been viewed as a mostly predictable response to abrasive grazing diets. Using kangaroos, an isolated marsupial radiation, we show that the ancestral vertical slicing function of grazing kangaroo molars prompted heavy investment from the late Miocene in thickened enamel, rather than hypsodonty. Grazing kangaroo enamel thickness overlaps some robust hominins, evincing an eclectic, thick-enamelled grazer guild. The success of vertically-chewing marsupials contrasts with their placental counterparts, which were overwhelmingly replaced by transversely-chewing ungulates. This inversion is explained by the pre-grassland extinction of most transversely-chewing marsupials, and the crucial advent of thick enamel. These results challenge the determinism of the browser-grazer transition, and implicate extinction, and ensuing innovation, as causes of unpredictability in evolution.