Rising minimum temperatures contribute to 50 years of shifting Arctic and boreal butterfly communities in North America

Abstract

AbstractGlobal climate change has been identified as a major driver of observed insect declines, yet in many regions there are critical knowledge gaps for how communities are responding to climate. Poleward regions are of particular interest because warming is most rapid while biodiversity data are most sparse. Building on recent advances in occupancy modeling of presence-only data, we reconstructed 50 years (1970-2019) of butterfly population trends in response to rising minimum temperatures in one of the most under sampled regions of the continent. Among 90 modeled species, we found that cold-adapted species are far more often in decline compared to their warm-adapted, more southerly distributed counterparts. Further, in a post-hoc analysis using species traits, we find that species range-wide average annual temperature and wingspan are a consistent predictor of occupancy changes. Species with warmer ranges and larger wingspans were most likely to be increasing in occupancy. Our results provide the first look at macroscale butterfly biodiversity shifts in a critically under sampled region of North America. Further, these results highlight the potential of leveraging the wealth of presence only data, the most abundant source of historical insect biodiversity. New approaches to the modeling of presence only data will match recent increases in community science participation with sparse historical records to reconstruct trends even in poorly sampled regions.