Phenological turnover matters when making trait-based predictions of plant-pollinator interactions
Aoife Cantwell‐JonesiD, Juliet EversoniD, Olivia K. BatesiD, Abdullah M. R. Al‐Hayali, George Henry AlleniD, Lucas Berard, Frauke CaliebeiD, Suzannah Egleston, Lucia Hudson, J Leichter James, L. Shannon Jung, Moganavalli Kattan, Renee Lejeune, Johan Svedin, Silas van Brakel, Manon van Unen, Jason M. TylianakisiD, Keith LarsoniD, Richard J. GilliD
Abstract
1. Understanding the processes determining species interactions is key to predicting and safeguarding ecological networks under rapid environmental change. One approach to estimating interactions is to use morphologies of taxa interacting across trophic levels to reveal suites of traits they are more likely to interact with (i.e. a trait niche). 2. Previous work studying these morphological trait niches has typically used interactions between species that are pooled in space and time. However, species assemblages, and the traits of individuals within species, can change across even small landscapes over a season, leading to morphological trait space being dynamically reshaped. Therefore, it is unclear how morphological trait turnover affects our inferences of trait niches, and our ability to answer this is in part limited by a lack of individual-level trait data. 3. Here, we directly address this by studying a montane Arctic plant-pollinator community over five growing seasons (>1,300 hours of fieldwork). Specifically, we linked every recorded plant-bumblebee interaction with the traits of the bee individual involved (n = 1,150), to investigate 1) whether plant taxa (n = 10) exhibited bee trait niches by interacting with specific regions of multidimensional trait space of visiting bumblebees, and 2) how our inference of these trait niches was affected by considering bumblebee trait turnover and plant taxon turnover. 4. When not considering turnover (interactions in space and time are pooled), plant taxa demonstrated bee trait niches. However, next we considered how bee trait space is reshaped over the elevational and seasonal gradient (especially with the emergence of different castes), and how this reshaping co-occurs with different spatiotemporal ranges of the plant taxa. From this we found the degree to which plant taxa exhibited trait niches declined significantly, and that seasonal reshaping of bee trait space was the primary driver of this trend. 5. Overall, in highly dynamic systems, like the Arctic, overlooking community turnover could mask and even overestimate the ability of morphology to explain interactions. Hence, determining how morphological traits of individual interaction partners are in phenological synchrony at localised scales will be fundamental to understanding the role morphology plays in underpinning plant-pollinator interactions.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papers- Citations
- 2
- FWCI
- 1.89
- Field percentile
- top 15%
- Organism
- Assay
- Research Focus
- Approach
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Seasonal variation mediates the importance of species attributes in plant-pollinator interactions
Jose B. Lanuza, Alfonso Allen‐Perkins, … Tiffany M. Knight·bioRxiv·Jul 22, 2026
- Coevolution of phenological traits shapes plant-pollinator coexistence
François Duchenne, Virginia Domínguez‐García, … Ígnasi Bartomeus·Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological SciencesPeer-reviewed·Feb 11, 2026
- Phenological shifts drive biodiversity loss in plant--pollinator networks
M. Franco-Cisterna, R. Ramos-Jiliberto, … D. P. Vazquez·bioRxiv·Apr 3, 2020
- Spatiotemporal shifts in the role of floral traits in shaping tropical plant-pollinator interactions
Y. Klomberg, R. Tropek, … S. Janecek·bioRxiv·Oct 16, 2020
- Climate warming changes synchrony of plants and pollinators
J. Freimuth, O. Bossdorf, … F. M. Willems·bioRxiv·Jan 10, 2021
- Skewness in bee and flower phenological distributions
M. Stemkovski, R. G. Dickson, … R. E. Irwin·bioRxiv·May 17, 2022