Orca vowels and consonants: convergent spectral structures across cetacean and human speech

The vocal communication system of orcas (Orcinus orca) has so far been analyzed primarily in terms of the fundamental frequency (F0) modulations, i.e. the frequency of their phonic lips vibration. The calls have been divided into clicks, pulsed calls, whistles and types thereof. By analyzing 61 hours of on-orca acoustic recordings and controlling for the effect of high-frequency components (HFC) and F0, we report structured formant patterns in orca vocalizations including diphthongal trajectories. Broadband spectrogram analysis reveals previously unreported formant patterns that appear independent of F0 and HFC and are hypothesized to result from air sac resonances. This study builds on the recent report of formant structure in vowel- and diphthong-like calls in another cetacean, sperm whales (Physeter macrocephalus). Using linguistic techniques, we further demonstrate that some calls are reminiscent of human consonant-vowel sequences, featuring bursts or abrupt decreases in amplitude. We also show that individual sparsely distributed clicks gradually transition into high frequency tonal calls, which aligns with analysis of sperm whale codas as vocalic pulses. The paper makes methodological contributions to the cetacean communication research by analyzing orca vocalizations with both narrowband and broadband spectrograms. The reported patterns are hypothesized to be actively controlled by whales and may carry communicative information. The spectral patterns shown in this study provide an added dimension to the orca communication system that merits further analysis and demonstrates convergent evolutions of similar phonological features in cetaceans (orca and sperm whale) and human communication systems.