Nuclear phylogenomics clarifies the family-level backbone and gene-tree conflict in Zingiberales

Abstract

Zingiberales includes eight morphologically distinctive families, but its family-level backbone has remained unstable, especially around Musaceae, Heliconiaceae, Lowiaceae, and Strelitziaceae. We analysed 1566 low-copy nuclear genes from 52 samples, representing all eight families and Pontederia crassipes as outgroup. Concatenated maximum likelihood and multispecies coalescent analyses recovered the same backbone: ((Zingiberaceae, Costaceae), (Cannaceae, Marantaceae)) is sister to (Musaceae, (Heliconiaceae, (Lowiaceae, Strelitziaceae))). Penalized-likelihood dating placed the sampled crown group in the Late Cretaceous, with several deep family-level divergences occurring on short internodes. Analysis of 1248 rerooted gene trees showed that conflict is concentrated on these deep branches and in several shallow clades. HyDe tests of empirical and simulated matrices, each including 62,475 triples, did not support widespread ancient hybridization among the major family-level lineages after filtering against the simulated null model. The nuclear data recover a stable Zingiberales backbone, and the long-standing instability of several deep nodes is best explained by rapid early divergence and extensive incomplete lineage sorting.