Socioeconomics and biogeography jointly drive geographic biases in our knowledge of plant traits: a global assessment of the Raunkiaerian shortfall in plants
B. S. Maitner, R. Gallagher, J.-C. Svenning, M. Tietje, E. H. Wenk, W. L. Eiserhardt
Abstract
The traits of plants determine how they interact with each other and their environment, constituting key knowledge for diverse fields. The lack of comprehensive knowledge of plant traits (the "Raunkiaerian shortfall") poses a major, cross-disciplinary, barrier to scientific advancement. Spatial biases in trait coverage may also lead to erroneous conclusions affecting ecosystem management and conservation planning. Thus, there is an urgent need to assess the spatial completeness of plant trait data, understand drivers of geographic biases, and to identify solutions for filling regional gaps. Here, we leverage a comprehensive set of regional species checklists for vascular plants and trait data for 2,027 traits and 128,929 plant species from the TRY database to assess trait data completeness across the globe. We show that trait data availability in TRY is associated with socioeconomic and biological factors influencing sampling likelihood: trait completeness was positively associated with mean species range size, research expenditure, and human population density and negatively associated with endemism and vascular plant species richness. Integration of a second, regional trait database (AusTraits) more than doubled trait completeness for the continent covered, indicating that the creation and integration of regional databases can rapidly expand trait completeness. Plain Language SummaryThe traits of plants determine how they interact with each other and their environment. Our knowledge of plant traits is incomplete, limiting scientific advancement as well as our ability to manage ecosystems and plan conservation actions. We show that there are large biases in trait data availability which are associated with both biological factors (range size, endemism, species richness) and socioeconomic factors (research expenditure, human population density). We also show how regionally-focused efforts can help rapidly expand trait data availability.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papers- Organism
- Research Focus
- Approach
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- What we (don’t) know about global plant diversity
W. K. Cornwell, W. D. Pearse, … A. E. Zanne·bioRxiv·Aug 31, 2018
- The most abundant plant species of Eastern Australia and our knowledge of their traits
David Coleman, Mark Westoby, … Julian Schrader·bioRxiv·Dec 17, 2025
- Origin of plant trait data matters: Shared species of Northwestern Europe and the Pannonian Ecoregion have different trait values in the two regions
Judit Sonkoly, Péter Török·Acta Botanica HungaricaPeer-reviewed·Oct 21, 2025
- Global vascular plants reveal persistent gaps across taxa and ecoregions
Everton A. Maciel·bioRxiv·Aug 28, 2026
- Extracting and evaluating plant trait information from digital text in the Global Biodiversity Information Facility
Takuro Katori, Michio Oguro·bioRxiv·Mar 16, 2025
- GIFT - A Global Inventory of Floras and Traits for macroecology and biogeography
P. Weigelt, C. Koenig, H. Kreft·bioRxiv·Feb 1, 2019