Independent erosion of conserved transcription factor binding sites points to shared hindlimb, vision, and scrotum loss in different mammals

Abstract

Genetic variation in cis-regulatory elements is thought to be a major driving force in morphological and physiological change. However, identifying transcription factor binding events which code for complex traits remains a challenge, motivating novel means of detecting putatively important binding events. Using a curated set of 1,154 high-quality transcription factor motifs, we demonstrate that independently eroded binding sites are enriched for independently lost traits in three distinct pairs of placental mammals. We show that these independently eroded events pinpoint the loss of hindlimbs in dolphin and manatee, degradation of vision in naked mole-rat and star-nosed mole, and the loss of scrotum in white rhinoceros and Weddell seal. Our study exhibits a novel methodology to detect cis-regulatory mutations which help explain a portion of the molecular mechanism underlying complex trait formation and loss.\n\nAuthor SummaryEvolution has produced an astounding variety of species with incredibly diverse phenotypes. A central question in evolutionary developmental biology is how (and which) DNA evolves to encode all of these different traits. A prevailing hypothesis is that changes in regulatory DNA, short stretches of DNA which control the expression of protein-coding genes, drive important differences in trait formation between species. The basic building block of regulatory DNA is thought to be transcription factor binding sites, shortl genomic sequences which attract proteins whose central role is to control the rate of transcription. In this study, we asked whether the independent erosion of otherwise highly conserved transcription factor binding sites points to a trait shared between species which have undergone similar adaptations. We show that our method is able to point to the loss of hindlimbs in dolphin and manatee, poor vision in naked mole-rat and star-nosed mole, and loss of scrotum in Weddell seal and white rhinoceros. Overall, our study exhibits a means of detecting evolutionarily important genomic regions which help explain a portion of complex trait loss and retention.