bioRxivMicrobiologyPreprint
Statistical calibration of microbial suspensions in carrier controls during a textile disinfection ring trial
Abstract
IntroductionThe high number of uncontrollable variables in microbiological systems increases experimental complexity and reduces accuracy, potentially leading to data misinterpretation or uncorrectable errors. During an interlaboratory calibration analysis it was observed that the microbial logarithmic reduction (LR) caused by disinfectants depends not only on the type of disinfectant but also on the initial microbial load in the fabric carriers, which can produce a misinterpretation of the results. Fabric carriers are commonly used in standard tests such as EN16616 and ASTM2274. ObjectiveA method based on statistical calibration is proposed using a regression line between N0 (initial microbial load in the carrier) and LR to eliminate the influence of one on the other. ResultsAn example with Candida albicans is presented. Once the method was applied, the influence of N0 on LR was eliminated and the new LR values can be used for factorial experiments, for example, to check the efficacy of disinfectants or detergents without depending on the microbial load placed in the carrier.
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Bivariate confidence probability plots as a method to test the accuracy and variability of microbiological measures
A. Monleon Getino, AC Marca Home Care·bioRxiv·Nov 18, 2020
- Variable fluid mechanics explain why static efficacy tests overestimate sanitizer performance against Listeria
Yang Jiao, Jakob Baker, … Abigail B. Snyder·Applied and Environmental MicrobiologyPeer-reviewed·Jul 17, 2026
- Reduction of Listeria on stainless steel surfaces is impacted by sanitizer application method
Yang Jiao, Jakob Baker, … Abigail B. Snyder·bioRxiv·Apr 9, 2025
- Iterative Cochran's C test as a multivariate method to detect higher than expected variability: a microbiological inter-laboratory ring trial as a case-study
A. Monleon-Getino, AC Marca Home Care·bioRxiv·Nov 19, 2020
- Reproducibility problem with a proposed standard method to measure disinfection efficacy
J. Hilgren, M. Srikanth, … The Efficacy Working Group·bioRxiv·Mar 15, 2022
- General calibration of microbial growth in microplate readers
Keiran Stevenson, Alexander F McVey, … Teuta Pilizota·Scientific ReportsPeer-reviewed·Dec 13, 2016