Immediate methane and carbon dioxide release from exposed permafrost at an active retrogressive thaw slump in the Canadian Arctic

Abstract

The Arctic is warming rapidly, causing permafrost thaw and accelerating the release of greenhouse gases. Rapid thaw features such as retrogressive thaw slumps are increasing in frequency and severity across the Arctic; however, their associated greenhouse gas emissions are poorly constrained. Current estimates of emissions from retrogressive thaw slumps rely largely on laboratory incubations and carbon stock estimates rather than in-situ field measurements. Here we directly quantify methane and carbon dioxide fluxes from the exposed headwall of an active retrogressive thaw slump. We show that thaw immediately releases biogenic methane and carbon dioxide, originating from gases trapped within the frozen soil matrix. Microbial transcription of methyl-coenzyme M reductase suggests archaea carrying out methanogenesis at subzero temperatures are the source of trapped methane. Carbon emissions varied by an order of magnitude among cryostratigraphic units, reflecting differences in geomorphologic history, organic carbon and nitrogen content, and microbial community composition. Carbon emissions were highest from organic-rich paleo cryosols from the Late Holocene that contained abundant methanogenic archaea. We estimate that [~]300 kg C (CO2 equivalents) is emitted annually from the headwall of this small thaw slump (surface area of [~]1200 m2). Considering the thousands of active slumps and extensive coastal permafrost erosion across the northern continuous permafrost zone, such features may represent a growing natural source of GHG emissions. These findings indicate that current permafrost carbon feedback models underestimate GHG release by omitting the direct release of trapped gases stored in permafrost.