Comparing data-driven physiological denoising approaches for resting-state fMRI: Implications for the study of aging

Abstract

Physiological nuisance contributions by cardiac and respiratory signals has a significant impact on resting-state fMRI data quality. As these physiological signals are often not recorded, data-driven denoising methods are commonly used to estimate and remove physiological noise from fMRI data. To investigate the efficacy of these denoising methods, one of the first steps is to accurately capture the cardiac and respiratory signals, which requires acquiring fMRI data with high temporal resolution. In this study, we used such high-temporal resolution fMRI data to evaluate the effectiveness of several data-driven denoising methods, including global-signal regression (GSR), white matter and cerebrospinal fluid regression (WM-CSF), anatomical (aCompCor) and temporal CompCor (tCompCor), ICA-AROMA. Our analysis focused on each methods ability to remove cardiac and respiratory signal power, as well as its ability to preserve low-frequency signals and age-related functional connectivity (fcMRI) differences. Our findings revealed that ICA-AROMA and GSR consistently remove more heart-beat and respiratory frequencies, but also the most low-frequency signals. Our results confirm that the ICA-AROMA and GSR removed the most physiological noise at the expense of meaningful age-related fcMRI differences. On the other hand, aCompCor and tCompCor seem to provide a good balance between removing physiological signals and preserving fcMRI information. Lastly, methods differ in performance on young- and older-adult data sets. While this study cautions direct comparisons of fcMRI results based on different denoising methods in the study of aging, it also informs the choice of denoising method for broader fcMRI applications.