Hemispheric Dissociation in the Cognitive Control of Word Production

Abstract

This study investigated the hemispheric contributions of the inferior frontal gyrus (IFG) to word production across constrained and unconstrained tasks. In the present study, we used focal ring transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) in a sham-controlled, double-blind design, combined with a Picture-Word Interference (PWI) task and a picture description task. Fifty-four healthy young adults completed both tasks within the same stimulation sessions, receiving anodal stimulation over either the left or right IFG. Following task-specific data exclusions, 52 participants were included in each of the two task analyses. In the PWI task, categorically related distractors produced semantic interference and associatively related distractors facilitated naming in response times, consistent with previous findings. Stimulation did not affect response times. In error rates, the two stimulation sites modulated the associative effect in opposite directions. Anodal stimulation of the left IFG enhanced the associative advantage in error rates, whereas anodal stimulation of the right IFG produced the opposite pattern. In the picture description task, anodal stimulation of the right IFG increased speech rate, producing significant effects on words per minute, unpruned words per minute, and syllables per minute. No equivalent effects emerged in the left IFG group. Lexical diversity and utterance length were unaffected by stimulation. Taken together, these findings provide convergent evidence for a hemispheric dissociation in word production. The right IFG appears to contribute to the regulation of speech output and the control of distractor interference, whereas the left IFG appears to support the retrieval and selection of word meanings.