Trophic strategies explain the ocean niches of small eukaryotic phytoplankton

A large fraction of marine primary production is performed by diverse small protists, and many of these phytoplankton are mixotrophs that also consume bacterial prey. However, the mechanisms structuring this diversity and its biogeochemical consequences remain poorly understood. Here we use isolates from seven major taxa to demonstrate tradeoffs between phototrophic and phagotrophic abilities. We then show that trophic strategy along the autotrophy-mixotrophy spectrum correlates strongly with global niche differences, across depths and across gradients of stratification and chlorophyll a. A model of competition shows that community shifts can be explained by greater fitness of faster-grazing mixotrophs when nutrients are scarce and light is plentiful. Our results illustrate how basic physiological constraints and principles of resource competition can organize complexity in the surface ocean ecosystem.