Distinct neural computations scale the violation of expected reward and emotion in social transgressions

Abstract

Traditional decision-making models conceptualize humans as optimal learners aiming to maximize outcomes by leveraging reward prediction errors (PE). While violated emotional expectations (emotional PEs) have recently been formalized, the underlying neurofunctional basis and whether it differs from reward PEs remain unclear. Using a modified fMRI Ultimatum Game on n=43 participants we modelled reward and emotional PEs in response to unfair offers and subsequent punishment decisions. Computational modelling revealed distinct contributions of reward and emotional PEs to punishment decisions, with reward PE exerting a stronger impact. This process was neurofunctionally dissociable such that (1) reward engaged the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex while emotional experience recruited the anterior insula, (2) multivariate decoding accurately separated reward and emotional PEs. Predictive neural expressions of reward but not emotional PEs in fronto-insular systems predicted neurofunctional and behavioral punishment decisions. Overall, these findings suggest distinct neurocomputational processes underlie reward and emotional PEs which uniquely impact social decisions.