Museum phylogenomics of extinct Oryctes beetles from the Mascarene Islands

Abstract

The evolution of island systems is characterized by processes that result in extreme morphological diversity, high endemism and high extinction rates. These dynamics can make phylogenetic reconstruction difficult, i.e. the extinct flightless Dodo from Mauritius was assigned to the family of doves only through DNA analysis of subfossils. Many insect species on islands have gone extinct through habitat loss, and face similar challenges to decipher their evolutionary history, however historical specimens have not yet been harnessed for phylogenomic reconstructions. Here, we employed historical museum specimens from the Mascarene Islands to generate the first whole-genome based phylogeny of three presumably extinct species of the rhinoceros beetle genus Oryctes. We compared their genomes with those of an extant Oryctes species from the island of Reunion, as well as a flightless Reunion-based species previously placed into the supposedly unrelated genus Marronus. We found that Marronus borbonicus belongs instead to the genus Oryctes and that the two Reunion-based species (O. borbonicus and M. borbonicus) are not sister taxa, suggesting two independent colonizations. The divergence time between them (<3Myr) overlaps with the volcanic formation of Reunion, likely indicating that M. borbonicus became flightless in situ. Our study showcases the power of genomes from insect museum specimens to address evolutionary questions in light of increasing extinction rates.