Net radiation estimation using the Brunt equation for clear sky emissivity and air and canopy temperatures for longwave radiation in well watered crops

Abstract

Net radiation (Rn) can be estimated using models that apply the Brunt equation for the incoming longwave radiation and air temperature (Tair) for the outgoing longwave radiation under reference conditions. This study aimed to estimate Rn using two previously regionally calibrated Brunt model, thereby eliminating the need site-specific calibration, and to assess whether Tair can be used as a substitute for canopy temperature (Tc) under well-watered crop conditions. Measurements were conducted in sesame and cotton fields during the first year and in a cotton field during the second year. Canopy temperature was measured during the second year, and the calculations were performed at hourly and daily time scales. Regardless of the method used to estimate sky emissivity or whether Tc or Tair was used, errors were greater at hourly time scale. The overall RMSE, MAE, Bias and KGE values at the daily time scales were 11.88, 9.13, 2.53, and 0.91, in the first year, and 13.45, 10.56, 0.10 and 0.74, in the second year, respectively. When using both regionally calibrated Brunt model, Rn simulation performance was superior to that of the Allen/FAO method. The comparison between Rn estimated using Tair and Tc, indicated statistical differences. Nevertheless, linear regression and error metrics showed that these differences were modest, especially at daily time scale. Thus, for practical purposes both regionally calibrated Brunt equations can be used to calculate clear-sky emissivity and improve Rn estimations, and Tair can be used as a substitute for Tc at the daily time scale under well-watered conditions.