Reply to Li et al. "Is Oculudentavis a bird or even archosaur?"
J. O'Connor, L. Xing, L. Chiappe, L. Schmitz, R. McKellar, G. Li, Q. Yi
Abstract
We welcome any new interpretation or alternative hypothesis regarding the taxonomic affinity of the enigmatic Oculudentavis khaungraae. However, here we demonstrate that Li et al. have failed to provide conclusive evidence for the reidentification of HPG-15-3 as a squamate. We analyse this specimen in a matrix that includes a broad sample of diapsid reptiles and resolve support for this identification only when no avian taxa are included. Regardless of whether this peculiar skull belongs to a tiny bird or to a bizarre new group of lizards, the holotype of Oculudentavis khaungraae is a very interesting and unusual specimen, the discovery of which represents an important contribution to palaeontology. Its discovery documents a potential new case of convergent evolution in reptiles, while highlighting the importance of amber deposits for documenting taxa not recorded in sedimentary deposits.
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- The tiny Cretaceous stem-bird Oculudentavis revealed as a bizarre lizard
A. Bolet, E. L. Stanley, … S. E. Evans·bioRxiv·Aug 9, 2020
- Is Oculudentavis a bird or even archosaur?
- The first dinosaur egg remains a mystery
L. J. Legendre, D. Rubilar-Rogers, … J. A. Clarke·bioRxiv·Dec 10, 2020
- Cryptovaranoides is not a squamate
Michael Wayne Caldwell, Chase Doran Brownstein, … Tiago R. Simões·bioRxiv·Apr 18, 2025
- A new pterosaur from Skye, Scotland and the early diversification of flying reptiles
E. Martin-Silverstone, D. M. Unwin, … P. M. Barrett·bioRxiv·Feb 14, 2022
- Unique dental arrangement in a new species of Groenlandaspis (Placodermi, Arthrodire) from the Middle Devonian of Mount Howitt, Victoria, Australia
Austin N. Fitzpatrick, Alice M. Clement, John Albert Long·PeerJPeer-reviewed·Dec 23, 2024