Tracking a major evolutionary transition to superorganismality

Abstract

Major transitions in evolution are associated with the loss of independent reproduction by formerly autonomous units. Termites provide a powerful system for studying this process because they exhibit diverse social systems in which worker developmental and reproductive potential declines with increasing colony-level organismality. However, the evolutionary sequence and developmental genetic basis of these transitions remain unresolved. Here, using comparative developmental transcriptomics across seven termite species that differ in workers' reproductive potential, we reconstructed the evolutionary history of termite social systems. We found that linear caste development, in which workers retain full reproductive potential, represents the ancestral state of termites. Bifurcated caste development, in which workers partially lose reproductive potential early in development, evolved independently multiple times, with two origins subsequently giving rise to superorganisms with unipotent, sterile workers. Ancestral gene regulatory network (GRN) reconstruction revealed that linear caste development evolved through retention of a juvenile-like worker state and co-option of a conserved developmental GRN characterizing hemimetabolous insect nymphal development, in which juvenile hormone, ecdysone and TGF-{beta} signaling pathways play central roles. The convergent evolution of bifurcated caste development repeatedly co-opted the GRN underlying linear caste development, heterochronically shifting its activity to earlier developmental stages. Finally, we found that the evolution of termite superorganisms involved somatization of the worker caste and co-option of a conserved endocrine GRN for terminal differentiation. Together, these findings uncovered repeated routes to reduced workers' reproductive potential through GRN co-option and highlight striking parallels between superorganism evolution in social insects and organismal evolution in metazoans.