Are seasonally plastic anti-predatory and desiccation tolerance traits developmentally linked?

Abstract

In many tropical areas, seasonal rainfall leads to distinct dry and wet seasons. Many butterflies developing under wet season conditions develop into adults with large ventral eyespots on the wing margins, whereas those developing under dry season conditions have smaller or no eyespots. In greener, wet season habitats, larger eyespots can divert predator attacks toward the wing margins, while reduced eyespot size improves camouflage in the dry leaf litter-dominated habitat during the dry season. However, the dry season is also characterised by higher desiccation stress than the wet season. We hypothesised that larvae developing under dry season conditions develop into adults with higher desiccation tolerance than those reared under wet season conditions. We tested this by rearing larvae of the butterfly Mycalesis mineus under simulated dry and wet season conditions and assaying the desiccation tolerance of the resulting adults. Butterflies reared in dry conditions survived longer under desiccation stress, lost lesser water during pupal-adult metamorphosis, and were heavier than those reared in wet conditions. We also tested the correlation between eyespot size and desiccation tolerance. A negative correlation between the traits would be expected if similar developmental pathways regulate them. Consistent with this expectation, individuals with smaller eyespots had higher desiccation tolerance. Our results demonstrate plasticity in desiccation tolerance, and suggest that predator avoidance and desiccation tolerance traits may share similar developmental pathways.