Exploring Neural Mechanisms of Language Switching: An fMRI Study Using a Functional Localizer Approach

Abstract

When bilinguals frequently switch between their first (L1) and second (L2) languages during speech production, we usually observe two phenomena: (i) language switch cost, where switching to a different language is more difficult than staying in the same one, and (ii) reversed language dominance, where L1 production becomes slower than L2 production. These effects are thought to reflect language control mechanisms, yet the underlying neural bases remain debated. In this study, we addressed this question by using the precision functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) based on functional localization. Forty-one Polish-English bilinguals performed a language switching task (LST), in which they named pictures in L1 or L2 based on color cues. We investigated mechanisms behind two indices of language control commonly observed in the LST. First, we asked whether the domain-general resources supporting language switch cost overlap with nonverbal task switch cost. Second, we asked whether reversed language dominance reflects changes in language activation in the language-specific system, or whether it is related to increased engagement of domain-general control mechanisms. Results indicated that the language switch cost and nonverbal task switch cost share overlapping domain-general neural mechanisms. Similar to the language switch cost, reversed language dominance primarily engages domain-general processes rather than language-specific resources. HighlightsO_LIfMRI combined with functional localization approach is implemented to examine the neural mechanisms underlying language switch cost and reversed language dominance. C_LIO_LILanguage switch cost relies on neural mechanisms shared with nonverbal switch cost within the Multiple Demand network. C_LIO_LIReversed language dominance is primarily supported by the domain-general rather than the language-specific mechanisms. C_LIO_LIDomain-general neural mechanisms play a pivotal role in bilingual language switching in speech production. C_LI