Behavioral Ecology and SociobiologyAnimal Behavior & CognitionPeer-reviewed journal article
Interindividual variability in flower pickiness by foraging bumblebees
Mélissa ArmandiD, Christoph BeckenbaueriD, Aurore Avarguès‐WeberiD, Mathieu LihoreauiD, Tomer J. CzaczkesiD
Abstract
Pollinators navigate complex and heterogeneous "flower markets", where floral resources vary in quality, availability, and spatial distribution. Bumblebees, as generalist foragers, visit numerous flowers during their foraging bouts, yet the factors influencing their flower choices and the individual differences in foraging behaviour remain poorly understood. Here, we tested how bees adjust their foraging in response to different reward structures. Bombus terrestris workers completed three foraging bouts in two artificial flower environments: one simulating a favourable environment with patches alternating high- and low-quality flowers (40% vs. 20% w/w sucrose solution), and the other a challenging environment with high-quality flowers alongside unrewarded ones (40% w/w sucrose solution vs. plain water). We hypothesised that bees would improve their foraging efficiency in both environments, but more rapidly in the more extreme one, where the greater reward difference creates stronger pressure to learn quickly. In both conditions, bees increased their sucrose intake per unit time over bouts. We also observed consistent differences in flower selectivity among individuals: in the favourable environment, bees that first visited high-quality flowers focused on them and avoided low-quality ones (became "picky"), while bees that first visited low-quality flowers kept visiting both types. Despite these differences, bees across environments and pickiness levels all reached similar sucrose intake rates by the third foraging bout, either by becoming more selective, collecting more sucrose solution, or reducing time spent foraging. These findings highlight the adaptability of bee foraging and suggest that early flower experiences may contribute to lasting individual differences in foraging behaviour. Significance statementBumblebees are highly efficient pollinators of wild plants and commercial crops, yet their foraging behaviour varies notably among individuals. Understanding why bees differ in their foraging decisions is crucial, as it affects how they collect resources. We show that individual Bombus terrestris workers rapidly adapt to flower patches with different reward qualities. Remarkably, a bees first flower visits have lasting effects: individuals that started with high-quality flowers consistently favoured them and avoided low-quality ones, while those that started with low-quality flowers continued to visit both types over time. Despite these differences, bees reached similar nectar intake rates after just three foraging trips, regardless of how selective they were. Our findings show that bees can quickly adjust their foraging behaviour, and that early experiences play a key role in how they exploit resources across different environments.
- Citations
- 1
- FWCI
- 0.83
- Field percentile
- top 34%
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Floral Cues and Flower Handling Tactics Affect Switching Decisions by Nectar-Foraging Bumble Bees
Minjung Baek, Jonathan S. Garcia, Daniel R. Papaj·Animal BehaviourPeer-reviewed·Aug 3, 2024
- Learning modifies attention during bumblebee visual search
T. Robert, K. Tarapata, V. Nityananda·bioRxiv·Oct 5, 2023
- Bumblebees do not prefer consistent floral scents over variable ones
Mélissa Armand, Lisa Zeilmann, … Tomer J. Czaczkes·bioRxiv·Mar 15, 2025
- Testing the peak-end rule in bumblebees: lack of preference for a higher-reward sequence when the final reward is disappointing
Mélissa Armand, Pauline Riemer, … Tomer J. Czaczkes·bioRxiv·Nov 25, 2024
- No decoy effect in bees: rewardless flowers do not increase bumblebees' preference for neighbouring flowers
Mélissa Armand, Leonhard Herrnberger, … Tomer J. Czaczkes·bioRxiv·Mar 24, 2025
- The Relationship Between Preference and Switching in Flower Foraging by Bees
D. R. Papaj, A. L. Russell·Behavioral Ecology and SociobiologyPeer-reviewed·Mar 19, 2024