Dynamic Network Analysis of Electrophysiological Task Data

Abstract

An important approach for studying the human brain is to use functional neuroimaging combined with a task. In electrophysiological data this often involves a time-frequency analysis, in which recorded brain activity is time-frequency transformed and epoched around task events of interest, followed by trial-averaging of the power. Whilst this simple approach can reveal fast oscillatory dynamics, the brain regions are analysed one at a time. This causes difficulties for interpretation and a debilitating number of multiple comparisons. In addition, it is now recognised that the brain responds to tasks through the coordinated activity of networks of brain areas. As such, techniques that take a whole-brain network perspective are needed. Here, we show how the oscillatory task responses from conventional time-frequency approaches, can be represented more parsimoniously at the network level using two state-of-the-art methods: the HMM (Hidden Markov Model) and DyNeMo (Dynamic Network Modes). Both methods reveal frequency-resolved networks of oscillatory activity with millisecond resolution. Comparing DyNeMo, HMM and traditional oscillatory response analysis, we show DyNeMo can identify task activations/deactivations that the other approaches fail to detect. DyNeMo offers a powerful new method for analysing task data from the perspective of dynamic brain networks. HighlightsO_LIWe show how oscillatory task response analysis can be carried out at the network level using two state-of-the-art methods: the Hidden Markov Model (HMM) and Dynamics Network Modes (DyNeMo). C_LIO_LIThe HMM and DyNeMo can identify oscillatory task responses that conventional time-frequency methods fail to detect. C_LIO_LIDyNeMo provides a more interpretable and precise network decomposition of the data compared to the HMM. C_LIO_LIThe dataset and (Python) scripts used to perform dynamic network analysis on task data are made publicly available. C_LI