Verification of radical pair mechanism predictions for weak magnetic field effects on superoxide in planarians

Abstract

Superoxide concentration and tissue regeneration in planarians exhibit a complex non-monotonic dependence on the strength of an applied weak magnetic field. While this is difficult to understand based on classical physics, a recently proposed quantum model based on a flavinsuperoxide radical pair mechanism could replicate the previously observed superoxide concentrations. However, this model also predicts increased superoxide concentrations for both lower and higher fields. This seemed to conflict with earlier experimental observations on blastema sizes, which were correlated with superoxide in the previously observed regime but were known not to follow the predicted trends for lower and higher fields. Motivated by this apparent contradiction, we here directly experimentally tested the predictions of the quantum model for superoxide for lower and higher fields. To our own surprise, our experiments confirmed the predictions of the radical pair model for superoxide, and incorporating interactions with multiple nuclei further improved the models agreement with the experimental data. While open questions remain regarding the exact relationship between blastema sizes and superoxide, which is revealed to be more complex than previously observed, and the detailed properties of the underlying radical pair, our results significantly support a quantum biological explanation for the observed magnetic field effects.