Global epistasis in ecosystems arises from resource constraints

Abstract

Global epistasis refers to the observation that the effect of a mutation or modification depends on the state of a biological system, not its detailed composition. Such patterns have been reported across biological scales, from proteins to organisms and ecosystems. In its simplest form, global epistasis appears as a linear relationship between the change in function or fitness due to a perturbation, and the background level of function or fitness. The mechanistic basis of global epistasis, particularly in ecological systems, remains unresolved. Here, we propose that in microbial communities, global epistasis describing the impact of adding a species to a community on function arises generically from constraints imposed by shared resource pools. We illustrate this mechanism in a single-species system growing on multiple substitutable resources, where global epistasis follows directly from nutrient limitation by an essential non-substitutable resource. We then extend this framework to multi-species communities competing for a single resource and show that the marginal effect of adding a species depends linearly on background community function, with a slope determined by the fraction of the resource claimed by the added species. We show that global epistasis persists in trophic cascades, but that facilitation and niche partitioning qualitatively break the linear dependence. This study provides a simple explanation for the appearance of global epistasis in ecosystems, and suggests that global epistasis should be a null expectation in ecosystems governed by competition. Our results propose that coupling between perturbations and shared resource pools might also help explain global epistasis at the organismal level.