bioRxivScientific Communication & EducationPreprint
The Open Field test as a tool for behavior analysis in pigs - is a standardization of setup necessary? A systematic review.
Abstract
The Open Field test is a common tool to measure anxiety and behavioral changes in rodents. However, scientific findings of rodent experiments may not translate adequately to humans and it has been shown that larger animal models might perform better in that regard. As a result, the number of published studies involving the Open Field test in domestic pig models is increasing. The aim of our review was to investigate the Open Field set-ups in published studies as well as similarity between performance and parameters published. Following the PRISMA guidelines for reviews we selected 69 studies for data extraction in this systematic review. We were able to determine specific set-up conditions such as size, duration and daytime for most of the included studies and found a high variability within these test specifiers. Results indicate a non-uniform performance of set-up including size, timing, parameters and additional combined tests such as the novel object test. We would like to point out the need for standardization of Open Field test for pigs in order to improve result, comparability and reduce inconsistencies.
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- On the intra-laboratory replicability of results in animal cognition research, obtained in animals that were not exposed to, or unaffected by, experimental manipulations - Exemplified by spatial learning in pigs (Sus Scrofa Domesticus) across 12 holeboard studies
F. Josef van der Staay, Alexandra Antonides, … Saskia Stefanie Arndt·bioRxiv·Jul 2, 2026
- Nature and nurture: comparing mouse behavior in classic versus revised anxiety-like and social behavioral assays in genetically or environmentally defined groups
J. Ronquillo, M. T. Nguyen, … L. R. Halladay·bioRxiv·Jun 16, 2023
- Reliability of Mouse Behavioural Tests of Anxiety: a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on the Effects of Anxiolytics.
Marianna Rosso, Robin Wirz, … Bernhard Voelkl·bioRxiv·Jul 28, 2021
- Experimenter familiarization is a crucial prerequisite for assessing behavioral outcomes and reduces stress in mice not only under chronic pain conditions
D. Segelcke, S. R. Talbot, … A. Tappe-Theodor·bioRxiv·Oct 3, 2022
- Convergent activity but divergent anxiety dimensions in male and female C57BL/6 mice across the open field and elevated plus maze
Guido Huisman, Lara S Caglayan, … Adriaan W. Bruijnzeel·bioRxiv·Sep 18, 2026
- The Horizontal Ladder Test (HLT) protocol: A novel, optimized, and reliable means of assessing motor coordination in Sus scrofa domesticus
X. Liu, A. G. Gutierrez, … S. E. Bergeson·bioRxiv·Dec 13, 2023