Uncertainty aversion predicts the neural expansion of semantic representations

Abstract

Correctly identifying the meaning of a stimulus requires activating the appropriate semantic representation among many alternatives. One way to reduce this uncertainty is to differentiate semantic representations from each other, thereby expanding the semantic space. In four experiments, we test this semantic-expansion hypothesis, finding that uncertainty averse individuals exhibit increasingly differentiated and separated semantic representations. This effect is mirrored at the neural level, where uncertainty aversion predicts greater distances between activity patterns in the left inferior frontal gyrus when reading words, and enhanced sensitivity to the semantic ambiguity of these words in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex. Two direct tests of the behavioral consequences of semantic-expansion further reveal that uncertainty averse individuals exhibit reduced semantic interference and poorer generalization. Together, these findings demonstrate that the internal structure of our semantic representations is shaped in a principled manner: aversion to uncertainty acts as an organizing principle to make the world more identifiable.